City hall advisors reject plan for new racecourse on Lincoln's West Common
PLANS to bring back racing on Lincoln's West Common have been rejected by advisors to City Hall.
The commons advisory panel, made up of councillors and interested groups voted 11 in favour of rejecting the plans.
-
A view of the old Grandstand from across the city's West Common.
Four of the panel, who make recommendations to the City of Lincoln Council's executive, abstained and one voted against the motion to reject.
The authority's executive will decide later in the year whether to accept the recommendation.
Carholme Ward councillor Neil Murray proposed the motion which said: "The commons advisory panel urges the City Of Lincoln Council to reject the plan put forward by Lincoln Racecourse Regeneration Company (LRRC) to build a racecourse on Lincoln's West Common.
"We do not view the West Common as a development opportunity. We believe that LRRC's plan would alter the nature of the common forever and deny access to much of it to Lincoln citizens and visitors.
"We urge the council to reaffirm its support for the 1985 City Of Lincoln Council Act, which protects all the commons from development."
The motion was seconded by panel member George Woolfenden, of the West End Residents' Association.
Karen Rastall, spokesman for LRRC Ltd, which launched a proposal to bring back racing in June, asked the panel earlier this month for a "heads of term lease" – a document which effectively leaves the door open for further discussion of the plan.
But scepticism reigned last night as panel members reasserted a lack of detail in the proposal meant they simply could not agree to anything.
Others agreed if the company wanted to create a masterplan, it should go ahead without the lease, which the company wants to demonstrate that the authority is interested in the project.
Vic Hughes, of Lincoln Civic Trust, said: "They are looking for this lease because there are investors. It is to give comfort to the investors by saying the City of Lincoln Council has asked us for more information and that they have serious interest."
Lincoln MP Karl McCartney is a director of the racecourse company, which has been keen to point out that no-one involved in the project would make money from it.
But Mr Hughes said: "It may be true there is no financial reward, but it must be noted that it is a £100 liability company, which means there are one hundred £1 shares not worth much now but should a lease be allowed then those shares are sold and they could be worth an awful lot of money."
The recommendation and points from the last meeting including the cost to citizens with the loss of their common, traffic disruption and lack of public consultation will also go to the council's executive which will meet in August.
44 Comments
View all
by loose windscreen, on the common
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 11:47PM
“Is Swiss Toni really Karl McCartney?
Because he sure does write like him!!!!”
by Shep, Lincoln
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 2:38PM
“It's a pea-brained scheme and will not get the go-ahead from City Council.
Even our council can't be half-witted enough to allow common land to be used to line the pockets of a few chancers whilst simultaneously mucking up the traffic for the majority.
If LRRC want to build a racecourse they should go ahead and buy some agricultural land and take the risk themselves.
To all the people that think a racecourse will bring boom and prosperity to the city - have you been to Market Rasen!?”
by Burt, Long Leys
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 8:43AM
“The advisory panel only advises.
This proposal has not been thrown out, the executive will make up their own mind.
If you support the idea of racing make your views officially known, if you do not support it do the same, simples.”
by Ted Heriot, Lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 10:49PM
“I have three comments:
1) The university brings enormous benefits to Lincoln, mainly in the shape of around £50 million per year into the local economy, 1,000 new jobs etc
2) City council officials haven't rejected anything yet, but I sincerely hope they will
3) I'm a member of the West End Community Forum and we've never had a meeting - it's all been done on email so far.
So everyone, please get your facts straight.”
by Jas, Lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 9:44PM
“This is for Terry.
The Long Leys Road area of Lincoln is considered by City Hall as the western part of the West End. An urban village was built there with developers making a huge profit out of it. It has been ten years since the first family of the urban village move in. Its residents are still waiting for community facilities. Nothing coming. Most have to use their cars to go anywhere. PC Coaches run a local bus service but this is nothing like which Stagecoach does for the rest of Lincoln. The residents are glad of the West Common. It is used by them. They would be cut off in walking into the city centre if horse racing is given the go ahead.
The question arising about the Grandstand - where would the Muslims go if this building is to become a conference centre for while remaining a community centre, on Fridays, the Grandstand is used their Mosque?”
by LincolnTeen, Lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 7:15PM
“@ Mushroom
Well yeah the University has been developed but it has no direct benifit to the locals nor the tourists.
What I'm saying is the proposed ventures to benifit the citys residents get rejected by city officials LincolnTeen, Lincoln”
by LincolnTeen, Lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 7:14PM
“@ Muschroom
Well yeah the University has been developed but it has no direct benifit to the locals nor the tourists.
What I'm saying is the proposed ventures to benifit the citys residents get rejected by city officials”
by Hev, Lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 6:27PM
“Lincoln's MP should be campaigning for the benefit of the people of Lincoln (like getting fast direct train connections to London, boosting local industry, etc). He was not elected to push his own personal investment schemes.
There was a good reason the race-course closed - it was obsolete and redundant - there is one not far away at Market Rasen. And the area now has long had other more popular recreational uses, including the golf course, and the stand is a leisure centre, etc. - was our MP expecting local people to make way for the MP's personal money making plans - for what is just another means of gambling.”
by fat fossie, lincoln
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 6:24PM
“I do wish you people would grow up, Lincoln is a small quiet back water were the locals (me included) are happy with the way things are and dont need the change and hassle that these bright ideas generate. Lets be honest the best thing you can do with the grandstand is bulldose it, im sure the council would give permission for a few dozen houses on that bit of land.”
by Colin Mair, Coningsby
Tuesday, July 27 2010, 5:51PM
“Here I am in Galway enjoying the Galway Races which bring an absolute fortune into this area. Next week I'll be in Lincoln where I still look forward to ONE idea that will grow the city positively into the future.”