More regulations needed to control this total circus
COUNCILLOR Tony Baxter's letter ('We've been denied rights to object to visit of circus', February 25) highlights the serious lack of regulation that animal circuses face.
Most people will be surprised to know that circuses with animals such as lions, tigers and elephants are able to move from town to town for most of the year with little control.
-

'PATHETIC': Ringmaster Martin Lacey trains his tigers to roll over at the Great British Circus .Picture: Ray Corke
Zoos and private keepers of such animals have to be licensed and inspected, but not circuses.
An animal trainer has to register with their local council, but there is no qualification required.
As Cllr Baxter notes, the public cannot object to a circus's application for an entertainment licence even if, as in this case, it is setting up next to houses.
Even when they are inspected, not everything may be revealed.
Last year, this circus kept three elephants chained for 11 hours every night, but this was done after RSPCA and council officers had visited.
Additionally, there will obviously be problems of public access to the land for the two weeks it is there.
Given that the circus has big cats and other animals classed as dangerous wild animals we would certainly urge residents to be cautious.
We would like to thank local residents who have already been in touch with us via our website to express their concerns at the circus and ask for our assistance.
We urge people to avoid any circus with animals and instead visit one of the many brilliant all-human shows that tour.
CRAIG REDMOND Campaigns Director, The Captive Animals' Protection Society, Manchester.
Your picture accompanying Tony Baxter's letter (February 25) about the Great British Circus was a real delight, summing up in one shot the real qualities of this outdated entertainment.
Three tigers, two of which are rolling over at the same time, follow commands given to them by their master.
Does this tell us how these awesome creatures live?
No.
Does it tell us how they hunt, breed, eat, or die?
No.
Does it tell us anything meaningful about tigers?
No.
It does, though, tell us that you can force an animal to do things that have no relevance to it, if you train it hard enough.
It does tell us that carting an animal from one end of the country to another for months on end in an alien environment so it can perform tricks, is a warped idea of caring. And it does tell us that some people think power and status can be gained by trying to make animals look pathetic and sad.
The only really pathetic looking figure in this picture however, is the one who is standing and holding the stick.
ALISON MOORE Lecturer in media, culture and communications, University of Lincoln.







4 Comments
by Mike, Waddington
Wednesday, March 03 2010, 8:17AM
“I see that Alison Moore expresses an opinion that does not support the animal acts that will appear under the Big Top. She is free to do so. However, by what virtue of being a Lecturer in media, culture and communications, University of Lincoln does she perhaps believe she has a greater say in this matter? Ms, do not qoute your qualification unless it pertains to the matter in hand. Use it when commenting on Media, Culture and Communications issues only please.”
by Not-a-big-circus-fan, Lincolnshire
Tuesday, March 02 2010, 6:39PM
“Reply to John - it's not quite the same thing. Yellow paint does no harm: keeping animals in a circus environment does them alot of harm, both physically and psychologically. I guess if you can see suffering, the natural response is to try to 'stop' it by whatever means you find appropriate.”
by John, Lincoln
Tuesday, March 02 2010, 10:58AM
“Just don't go. Why must people who don't want to go stop others from going? I don't like yellow paint, but I can accept that some people like it and so allow them to buy this as don't presume that everyone must accept my view on things”
by Craig and Alison supporter, Scunthorpe
Monday, March 01 2010, 6:23PM
“I absolutely agree with both of you! It's very refreshing to read this as it gives me hope that maybe it is only a minority of people that still believe it is acceptable for circuses to (mis)use animals as they do and ride roughshod over any opposition they encounter.”